FINANCIAL EDUCATION SERIES 2010
INVESTMENT AND INSURANCE PRODUCTS: NOT FDIC INSURED • NOT A BANK DEPOSIT •
NOT INSURED BY ANY FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AGENCY • NO BANK GUARANTEE • MAY LOSE VALUE
Homeownership also has enormous
emotional appeal. We like to own the
four walls that surround us. We tend
to show far greater patience with real
estate than with, say, our stock market
investments, in part because we don’t
get continuous price updates. Yes, our
homes may have lost value this year —
but because we don’t know precisely
how much, it is hard to get too upset.
Still, this doesn’t mean you should load
up on real estate. Here is why a home
can be a great investment and where
things might go wrong.
HITTING A HOME RUN
At first blush, real estate doesn’t seem
like any great shakes. According to
home finance corporation Freddie Mac,
home prices have climbed 4.3% a year
over the 30 years through year-end
2009, versus 3.5% for inflation.
Yet many folks fare far better than
these numbers suggest — thanks
to their mortgage and the way
it leverages gains. Let’s say you
purchase a $200,000 home. You
borrow $160,000 and put down 20%,
or $40,000, which represents your
initial home equity. If your home’s price
climbs 20% to $240,000, your home
equity will jump 100%, from $40,000
to $80,000.
Your home equity will also grow as
you pay down your loan balance. In
effect, you’re saving money with every
monthly mortgage payment.
On top of all this, there are the tax
breaks. You can deduct the interest on
up to $1 million of mortgage debt used
to acquire a first or second home.
You should also be able to deduct your
property taxes, as well as the interest
on $100,000 of home equity borrowing
used for any purpose. When you sell
your home, you can exclude up to
$500,000 in capital gains if you are
married and $250,000 if you’re single.
But maybe the biggest benefit comes
when you get the mortgage paid
off. At that point, you will still have
to pay property taxes, homeowner’s
insurance and maintenance costs. But
the monthly mortgage payment will be
gone — and with it one of your biggest
living expenses.
STRIKING OUT
Sound attractive? Now, consider
the downside. While a mortgage can
leverage your home’s price gains,
the math can also cut the other way.
Take the example above. What if your
home’s value drops from $200,000
to $160,000? Your $40,000 down
payment would be wiped out.
“You want to buy a house that’s
right size for your family — and
that you can see living in for a
continued
Your Best Investment? The Pros and Cons of Owning a Home
Congress has showered real estate with tax breaks, making it possibly the most tax-favored investment. Indeed,
even after the recent slump in property prices, many folks boast that their home is the best investment they
ever made.
Leverage also doesn’t come cheap.
Mortgage interest may be tax-
deductible. But it is still costing you
a bundle. If you pay $1 in mortgage
interest and you’re in the 25% tax
bracket, you will save 25 cents in
taxes — which means the other 75
cents is coming out of your pocket.
The costs don’t end there. When you
buy, you will be dinged for a home
inspection, title insurance, legal fees
and mortgage application costs. You
might also pay points to get a lower
interest rate on your mortgage.
Once you own the place, you will
have hefty ongoing costs, including
the monthly mortgage, homeowner’s
insurance, property taxes and
maintenance expenses. You may also
make home improvements, which
tend to be money losers. Time to sell?
You may lose 5% or 6% of the selling
price to the real estate brokerage
commission.
In fact, if you deduct all the costs of
homeownership from your home’s
price appreciation, you may find you
have made little or no money. For the
same reason, if you buy a vacation
home for your own use, you probably
won’t notch much of a profit.
SKIPPING THE RENT
That doesn’t mean homeownership is
a bum deal. Sure, you may not make
much on the appreciation, after all