Migrant seasonal workers in the European agricultural sector
7
number of reports indicate that migrant workers suffer slavery-like conditions in the olive oil, tomato
and grape industries in particular.
Strawberries, the red gold of Huelva, Spain
The province of Huelva produces more than 90 % of Spanish strawberries (of which Spain is the
world's top exporter). There, 6 000 hectares of strawberries produce about 300 000 tonnes a year
over a season stretching from February
to May, with a production peak from
April to May. Strawberry farms are
heavily reliant on the 50 000
seasonal
workers, mainly foreign migrant
workers, who come each year. Most
legal foreign guest workers are eastern
Europeans, followed by Africans –
mostly Moroccan women – and Latin
Americans. Hundreds of sub-Saharan
migrants live year-round in
shantytowns close to the fields. Spain's
agricultural model has been
questioned for years because of the
poor working and living conditions of
its migrant workers. The numerous
Moroccan women employed in the
strawberry fields are recruited in their
country of origin. They generally do not
speak Spanish. They come from rural
areas where they have left their families
and are sometimes illiterate, which
means they are entirely dependent on their employers. This situation can lead to exploitation and
abuse, as is well documented. In February 2020, the United Nations' Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty
and Human Rights, Philip Alston,
stated that some of these migrant workers lived in shantytowns
'with far worse conditions than a refugee camp, without running water, electricity or sanitation'.
The plight of female seasonal workers
Situations of exploitation and abuse seem to be exacerbated in the case of female seasonal workers,
who are often responsible for children. Fear of losing their jobs and of being unable to support their
families makes it difficult to escape employers' demands or report labour rights violations and
abuse. A study
conducted for the European Parliament in 2018 on the vulnerability to exploitation
of women migrant workers in agriculture in the EU and the need for a human rights and gender-
based approach exposed the severe exploitation of women in some regions of Spain (Huelva,
Almeria) and Italy (Ragusa in
Sicily). It describes how vulnerable Romanian or Moroccan women
recruited as seasonal labour work and live in inhumane conditions, suffering threats, blackmail,
violence and sexual abuse as an intrinsic part of an organised system of exploitation.
Cases of exploitation of migrant seasonal workers are not limited to southern EU countries. Reports
show abusive and exploitative practices in other EU Member States such as Germany, the
Netherlands and Sweden, where recourse to a migrant seasonal workforce is a structural component
of agri-food production.
Undeclared work in agriculture
Undeclared work is more prevalent in the agricultural sector
than in the EU economy in general, but its magnitude is
difficult to measure. According to a study conducted for the
European Platform tackling undeclared work, around a third of
EU agricultural employees do not have a written contract of
employment. This figure is confirmed by the European
Federation of Trade Unions in the Food, Agriculture and
Tourism sectors
EFFAT. ILO reports higher figures: some 61.2%
of the EU agricultural labour force would be engaged in
informal employment (defined as persons whose main job
lacks basic social or legal protection or employment benefits).
Unregistered employment in the agricultural sector would be
highest in Greece, Poland and Romania (above 90 % of all
agricultural employees), and lowest in the Czech Republic and
Sweden. It is widely recognised that a large proportion of
migrant seasonal workers are engaged in undeclared work.
They not only suffer from a lack of access to social security but
also access to information about their rights and a lack of
support. Their vulnerability makes them potential victims of
exploitation by intermediaries and employers.