On Accuracy: e components of this rubric each require that students demonstrate
historically defensible content knowledge. Given the timed nature of the exam, the essay
may contain errors that do not detract from the overall quality, as long as the historical
content used to advance the argument is accurate.
On Clarity: ese essays should be considered rst dras and thus may contain
grammatical errors. ose errors will not be counted against a student unless they obscure
the successful demonstration of the content knowledge and skills described above.
Scoring Notes
A. esis and Argument Development (2 points)
a) esis
Responses earn one point by presenting a thesis that makes a historically defensible claim
that responds to all parts of the question (1 point).
An acceptable thesis would make a historically defensible claim that would evaluate
the extent of change and continuity in African Americans’ lives in the South during the
period 1865 to 1905. e thesis must address both change and continuity, but it does not
need to treat each equally.
Examples of acceptable thesis:
•
Although slavery was eliminated, sharecropping replaced it and still resembled slavery
in form and practice. Sometimes African Americans were sharecroppers on the same
plantation or land that they had worked as slaves.
•
Although constitutional amendments provided civil rights for African Americans,
these civil rights were severely limited in practice and later through Jim Crow laws, or
segregation laws, in the South.
•
Radical Republicans and the federal government initially made concerted eorts to
achieve greater economic, political, and social equality for African Americans, but
over time these eorts declined.
•
Although African Americans gained new rights, over time White people used racially
targeted terrorism and violence to subordinate African Americans in the South.
•
Although the Fieenth Amendment gave African Americans the right to vote,
the ability to do so was curtailed over time by mechanisms such as literacy tests,
grandfather clauses, poll taxes, and the fear of violence.
•
In the period 1865 to 1905, the lives of African Americans in the South remained
much as they were in the period prior to the Civil War. Although no longer enslaved,
African Americans in the South aer 1865 continued to experience violence and
exclusion from economic, social, and political equality.
•
Although they continued to suer violence, discrimination, and hardship, African
Americans in the South experienced a great deal of positive change in the period aer
1865, including economic independence and political representation.
29
Sample Questions AP U.S. History Exam